Lusitania Medal - Karl Goetz' satire at LusitaniaMedal.com

 

Specific Gravity—making determinations of the relative density of a material in order to distinguish alloys and group like materials.

Taking specific gravity measurements is an important (though not the only) means of establishing whether a particular medal is genuine or a fake. If you have specific questions about how to perform the following, please feel free to email me for help.

I have an Ohaus Cent-O-Gram balance scale. It reads to the hundredth of a gram and seems pretty accurate. It's sensitive to room drafts, so if there is even the slightest breeze you need to close the window or otherwise isolate it from the air currents. It has the advantage of being able to take specific gravity (SG) determinations as shown in the following photographs.
To determine the SG of an item first weigh it normally. The Ohaus has a pan into which you place the specimen (I didn't do it for this photo, but you get the idea). On the Cent-O-Gram you manipulate the poises (the little weights on the bars at the top) to calculate the weight. You can buy electronic balances now that also have the capability to do SG, but not all of them do. Check before you buy a scale to be sure that it can perform this useful function. I'd also restrict my choices to a scale that can read to the hundredth of a gram (X.XXg).
Take a very thin piece of wire and bend it so it can hold the specimen. I use a piece of copper wire from my wife's beading hobby, but you could probably use fishing line or whatever. The nice thing about the copper wire is it's flexible, but retains the shape you bend it in to so you can reuse it over and over. Make a big loop to hold the specimen and a smaller loop on top to attach it to your scale for weighing..
Hook your wire up to the specimen. Make sure it's fairly well centered and tight enough that the specimen won't slip out.
Following the directions for your scale suspend the specimen from the appropriate place on your device and make sure it's completely immersed into a glass of water. Before you do so it helps to wet your fingers and liberally rub the specimen so to reduce the number of air bubbles once you immerse it (air bubbles introduce error). Weigh your specimen while it's suspended into the water. Don't let any part of it rest on the bottom of the glass or stick up above the water. I wouldn't even allow it to touch the side of the glass (though it can come close)—all of these would introduce error.

Once you finish with the weighings  you'll have two numbers:

        A = weight of the specimen in air (the way you would normally weigh the item)

        B = weight of the specimen while suspended in water.

Now you can perform the following calculation:

        Specific Gravity = (A/(A-B))*0.9983

For example, if the weight in air (A) is equal to 60.89 grams and the weight in water (B) is equal to 54.13 grams, then:

        (60.89/(60.89-54.13))*0.9983 = 8.9921

This value is representative of a good quality bronze such as Goetz used. Note that SG is a "unitless" value in that it simply expresses a ratio of the mass of an item to the mass of water of an equal volume. It's an arbitrary number, but useful for determining the type of alloy.

 

All material on this site copyrighted, 2004, G. Burns